Love Rules.

“Love Rules.” That’s the text message I received from Greg this afternoon. Eagerly, I had messaged him earlier in the day after hearing that the California Supreme Court overturned the ban on same-sex marriage. I had texted something like “YAY California!,” I think. It was the first time I felt a real sense of pride about living in this state, one foreign to my upbringing.

Greg is one of the many LGBT friends and mentors I have encountered during the last four years at Santa Clara. Like any other demographic, some of these friends are in long-term relationships, others are single, and some are other places in between. They are some of the most important people in my life, whatever their relationship status. Having said that, I cannot describe the overwhelming sense of joy and relief and justice that I felt when I heard this great political news today. Marriage (or no marriage) never affected my view of LGBT people or their romantic relationships–I naturally think of some couples I know as if they were married, just like my own parents–but in this very concrete judicial decision I had a deep sense of how much it symbolically mattered for my friends’ lives, and the many ways in which this tangible stride toward equality had the potential to inform the ways they are perceived by others.

“Love Rules” –those two little words captured the relatively recent formation of my own views about LGBTQ folk. I came to college generally indifferent about gay and lesbian people. I knew few, especially those who were out, and honestly, if I were asked about homosexuality I would have likely said, “It is probably wrong,” hesitantly referencing the Bible or popular Christian reasonings on the issue. It was not until I fell in love with certain people, and experienced the genuine goodness of their love and faith and hope–only to discover later that these individuals were gay and lesbian people–that I came to realize that I could not, actually, “hate the sin but love the sinner.” It was impossible to love as Jesus loved while “hating” a formative aspect of their identity. Just as I easily recognized that no one could hate women but really love ME, I could not separate my love and affection for my friends from their sexualities.

Love ruled–it won out over the awkwardness of unfamiliarity, over the passages that I had once read as dismissals of homosexuality, over the fear I held about standing up to my community–especially my Christian community–on an issue that many people would hold against me.

And isn’t that the kind of love we associate with God? A love that can overrule all of our pre-conceptions? A love that is bigger than even the supposed Christian truths that we try to glimpse with our human minds? If we ultimately believe that Love Rules above all, then we are necessarily vulnerable to surprise. To changing our minds. To being overturned.

Advertisement

4 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

4 Responses to Love Rules.

  1. Chris Bates

    I love you. And California is amazing.

  2. Λεωνίδας

    It was impossible to love as Jesus loved while “hating” a formative aspect of their identity.

    I’m not sure I buy this..

    Consider this example:
    Some guy grows up in an abusive family where his father beats his mother. He grows up and for whatever psychological reason he has abusive tendencies towards women.

    It seems this inclination is a formative aspect of his identity. I can’t help but hate the fact that he is that way. But I don’t see any reason why I can’t love him in the midst of that.

    Just as I easily recognized that no one could hate women but really love ME, I could not separate my love and affection for my friends from their sexualities.

    In a similar way, no one can hate gays and still love an individual gay person. But that’s not hating the sin and loving the sinner – that’s hating the sinner and loving the sinner.

  3. Anonymous

    How interesting – a devout Catholic girl who majored in “gender studies” at a radical leftist school, has dear friends in the so-called “LGBT” community and feels secure enough to announce to them her apparentl joy over Prop 8.

    Just…wow.

  4. Jessica Coblentz

    Dear Anonymous,

    Thank you very much for reading my blog, and for participating in the conversation by posting a comment.

    It saddens me to think that the combination of my devout Catholic faith, educational background, and commitment to the LGBT community surprise you. People like me are a major part of the reality of the Catholic Church today.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s